Sign up now

Sign up for TPRB – the Treatment Practitioner's Research Bulletin


TPRB Home Past Issues Continuing Education Editorial Board About TPRB



Can Comprehensive Integrated Treatment Improve Outcomes?
November 2008

Email
Email
Print
Print
Research Summary and Comments

The prevailing approach to addressing co-occurring mental-health and substance-use disorders has been to treat them separately. To determine whether an integrated approach improves outcomes, researchers implemented the Comprehensive Continuous Integrated System of Care (CCISC) treatment model in a residential program for homeless men and women with mental health and substance use disorders. The CCISC model combines several evidence-based treatments in one program. Comprehensive screening and assessment tools* were administered at the start of the program and at 6-month follow-up. Of the 96 patients who enrolled in the program, 76 completed follow-up assessments.

  • Significant improvements were identified in mental health symptoms, frequency of past-month drug use, abstinence from alcohol or drug use, housing status, and employment from baseline to follow-up.
  • Frequency of past-month alcohol use did not change significantly.

*The Government Performance and Results Act, the Residential Follow-back Calendar, the Brief Symptom Inventory, and the Comorbidity Program Audit and Self-Survey for Behavioral Health Services.

Comments by Michael Boyle, MA
The findings of this before-after observational study support the effectiveness of CCISC in treating co-occurring mental health and substance abuse disorders, but the study lacked a comparison group, and a randomized clinical trial is needed to provide stronger evidence. Such a study would be challenging to design and implement, but without one, it will be difficult to argue for challenging organizational inertia to change the current, usually segregated, approach to care. 

Reference:
Harrison, ML, Moore, KA, Young MS, et al. Implementing the Comprehensive, Continuous, Integrated System of Care Model for Individuals with Co-Occurring Disorders: Preliminary Findings from a Residential Facility Serving Homeless Individuals. J Dual Diagn. 2008;4(3):238–259.