Stay Informed

Sign up for news & alerts

Already signed up?
Login here

take action
For every $1 states spend dollar sign on substance misuse and addiction, 94 cents go to shovel up the consequences instead of for treatment and prevention. TELL YOUR LEGISLATORS

What Can I Do?



Continuing Education
Free online courses for addiction counselors LEARN ONLINE

Get Help
Need alcohol or drug help for yourself or someone else? GET HELP

 

Health Consultation Increases Healthy Student Behavior
November 5, 2008

Share Share Email
Email
Print
Print
SubscribeSubscribe
Research Summary

Research out of the University of Florida's (UF) College of Health and Human Performance suggests that brief consultations with health professionals effectively encourages college students to limit their alcohol consumption, marijuana use and drunk driving.

Researchers separated 303 college students into a control group where students were provided with promotional materials and pamphlets about the dangers of smoking, and an experimental group where students briefly met with health professionals for a one-on-one health consultation about risk behaviors.

The brief health consultations proved to be more effective at reducing students' negative health habits and increasing positive ones, such as getting more sleep. "There were significant outcomes for those students who had the brief multiple behavior interventions," said study author Chad Werch, director of UF's Addictive & Health Behaviors Research Institute. "It goes beyond these particular behaviors; they are actually saying the quality of their lives has improved."

Werch said key factors in the model were that health professionals addressed multiple negative health habits and that the consultations were brief. "The whole idea is that these interventions are time-limited -- they are not intensive or extensive," Werch said. "The emphasis is on motivation."

Health professionals highlighted positive aspects of the students' self-image and avoided negative ones. "The idea that there are some central mechanisms like image that might contribute to reducing risk across multiple areas of functioning is intriguing to public health and seems critical for targeting risk reductions in addiction," said study co-author Carlo DiClemente, a psychology professor at University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

The research was published Sept. 18, 2008 in the online version of the Annals of Behavioral Medicine.

This article summarizes an external report or press release on research published in a scientific journal. When available, links to the sources are provided above.

COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:

Posted by Erin G @stonehill college on 06 Nov 08 01:53 PM EST
To me, it is hard to say whether the results of this study are actually applicable in the real world. In the first place, the article fails to mention if the students in the pamphlet and literature group were made to read the material or if it was simply handed to them. I think that if people are only given this information but are not required to read it, chances are very few will do so. As a result, literature probably will not impact negative decision-making. On the other hand, I can understand how the students in the consultation group were more positively influenced, since they were required to interact and learn from an actual living, talking human being. However, the question is: how much of an impact can consultations like these have in the real-world? Meeting with a health care professional to talk about the consequences of negative health habits would only inspire healthier decision-making if it were the individual’s CHOICE to attend. I think that follow-up research should be done to determine exactly how this consultation model can be applied most effectively in influencing individual’s decision-making.

Posted by CaitinR@stonehillcollege on 17 Nov 08 11:11 AM EST
I agree with Erin in wondering if this study can be applied in a real world situation. I believe that the person must be willing to go to a consultation and be willing to make the changes necessary. One student can receive a one on one consultation with a professional and completely disregard everything said to them if they are not willing to change. This literature also does not mention whether the students were followed up in seeing if they maintained the healthier lifestyle, or fell back into their old routines after a period of time. While continuing contact with students can reinforce the message of healthy living, it is hard to demand that every college student must meet with a counselor on a regular basis. The next step in researching this idea would be to follow up as to how long they maintained their lifestyle after the consultation, or seeing if routine contact with the professional would increase the numbers of people who changed their lifestyle.

Posted by mikeg@stonehillcollege on 20 Nov 08 02:50 PM EST
I think that Erin and Caitlin bring up valid points. The students in the pamphlet and literature group most likely were not prompted to change their habits. However, if an individual were to have consultations with a counselor they might actually want to make healthier life decisions. I think that motivation definitely has a major role in a healthy lifestyle. Motivation and consultation might have a greater impact on ones decision to live a healthy life. The literature group did not have the human interaction which might not motivate a person to change their lifestyle. This study needs some follow up research. Perhaps following up with the consultation students and lit group would give some validity to the researchers initial results. Otherwise I don't think the results are applicable to the real world.

Posted by nickm@sc on 20 Nov 08 03:54 PM EST
I think the findings of this study are great. It seems to me that colleges and universities in America could really raise health awareness by simply having these one-on-one consultations as part of the freshmen orientation sessions and it could be a quite beneficial and low cost venture. I think that this more personal approach to talking about health issues would be more effective than just handing out pamphlets and having lectures with 100-200 people, which is what many colleges do now.

Posted by CaitlinW@Stonehill College on 29 Nov 08 03:09 PM EST
I really liked this research study and I feel that the results can be used for increasing positive healthy behaviors for college students. I think it is important to hold forums that outline the risks and benefits of drug use and other health related issues. It is important to make students aware of how important it is to take care of themselves. Many students often find college to be a very stressful and difficult time trying to balance studying, work, internships, and taking care of themselves. In those stressful times, they might turn to unhealthy or risky behaviors. Programs should be offered that emphasize positive behaviors. For example, Stonehill College offers students small workshops on stress management, sleeping, exercising, and eating healthy. While I do not think that only having prevention or forums that discuss health related issue is enough, proper treatment programs and options need to be in place as well, but it is a start in the right direction. There should be more positive, healthy programs on campuses.

Posted by Joaquin S@Stonehill on 04 Dec 08 01:32 PM EST
I have to say that I agree with all the individuals who have written before me. Motivation is very much the main factor as to why people become better or even beat their addictive behavior. Its also very interesting as to just simple counseling can change people's behavior patterns from becoming addictive ones. There is a lot to say about how simple education can make people smarter in regards to dangerous behavior. I wonder if a study like this would prompt other colleges to have programs where students can obtain counseling about drug and alcohol use around campus and even back in their neighborhoods.

Posted by Meg B - Stonehill on 08 Dec 08 10:28 PM EST
I also think that the results of this research could be flawed. I feel that when students first are introduced to information about how to change negative behaviors there could be a shock value that could cause them to change their ways. However, often times such information only changes behaviors temporarily. I feel that it is a well known fact that drinking and smoking is bad for your you, while getting more sleep would be beneficial. However, just because you changed someones behaviors for a weekend does not mean that it will last the entire year. If students CHOSE to attend this meeting, I feel that they were probally the type of people who would want to make a change, therefore showing results that might not necessarily reflect what would happen if an entire student body were to be exposed to the literature.

Posted by AshleyC@Stonehill on 09 Dec 08 05:09 PM EST
It seems as though it would be obvious that meetings with real counselors would be more influential on student's lives than just pamphlets on the dangers. I feel the in person counseling was beneficial to the students to an extent, but for it to have been a life changing meeting seems hard to believe. I am not sure of how many college students would feel so inclined to get this counseling done and how many of them would actually feel that there is that much of an impact on their lives from these meetings. If an individual was motivated enough to participate in this counseling, then I think it would be more influential for their lifestyle changes they desire.

SUBMIT A COMMENT:

Note: Comments are now held for moderator approval. More info

Name:

Comment:
(limit 250
words)

Enter this word
(help):
Change

GUIDELINES: 
Please keep comments on-topic, courteous, clean, non-commercial, and within the word limit.
Read the complete guidelines