Stay Informed

Sign up for news & alerts

Already signed up?
Login here

take action
For every $1 states spend dollar sign on substance misuse and addiction, 94 cents go to shovel up the consequences instead of for treatment and prevention. TELL YOUR LEGISLATORS

What Can I Do?



Continuing Education
Free online courses for addiction counselors LEARN ONLINE

Get Help
Need alcohol or drug help for yourself or someone else? GET HELP

 

U.S. Considers Paying Off Afghan Poppy Farmers
July 30, 2009

Share Share Email
Email
Print
Print
SubscribeSubscribe
News Summary

As additional U.S. forces push deep into southern Afghanistan -- where the Taliban is the strongest and the cultivation of opium is the most lucrative -- the Obama administration is considering paying local farmers to cease planting poppies, the Associated Press reported July 21.

The U.S. wants to stop the Taliban from profiting from the heroin trade; insurgents earned as much as an estimated $70 million from drug trafficking last year, according to the United Nations.

Critics of the payout proposal say the farmers will take the U.S.'s money but won't stop producing the crop, especially since the Taliban provides them with a market and pays them up front.

The administration is still deciding whether to offer the payments, which would likely be handled by civilians under the direction of the State Department.

Currently, the U.S. relies on local authorities to fight heroin trafficking. Under the Bush administration poppy crops were destroyed, but that approach is believed to have motivated Afghan farmers to support the Taliban.    

COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:

Posted by LMassey on 30 Jul 09 09:17 AM EDT
Are you serious that we are going to send money to Africa??? How can this even be seen as a solution to this problem? No ability to monitor this or to enforce it. I support Obama, but this is rediculous.

Posted by me on 30 Jul 09 10:06 AM EDT
paying them? seriously? i thought our president was supposed to be intelligent. you're not going to convince them to stop but if you really wanted to stop them, you'd have to just destroy the fields, but where does that get us and the "view of us in the world" oh oh, and where is this money supposed to come from that we're going to pay them with? oh boy, another trillion $$$ in debt, yay.

Posted by rcount on 30 Jul 09 10:12 AM EDT
How stupid is this administration? Even if they would agree to stop the growing, the Taliban would kill them.

Posted by Pete on 30 Jul 09 03:56 PM EDT
I agree with the comments above, except about sending money to Africa. Afghanistan is nowhere near Africa, it's in south central Asia! Aside from that, enforcement would be very difficult, not to mention the potential for corruption with huge sums of cash being distributed for local payouts. Also, as Rcount pointed out, even if we successfully managed to pay the farmers to stop growing, the Taliban wouldn't hesitate to kill the farmers if they refused to immediately start planting and harvesting opium again. We are too quick to forget just how brutal the Taliban is.

Posted by Rob Fleming on 30 Jul 09 05:07 PM EDT
We've been paying American farmers to not grow cotton, wheat, soybeans, etc. for years, but that's probably good politics and bad economics. You could buy another crop for more than the price of opium, but the Taliban would probably raise the price, in dollars or blood, that they paid for growing poppies. It all comes down to demand, and making sobriety more attractive than addiction, because if you stopped all the heroin at the source, addicts would switch to meth, or huffing gasoline, or whatever. It's like busting street drug sellers - their friend or their cousin just moves into their slot. You have to fill the niche with an alternative, not just take a substance or a seller out of the niche. Not easy, but join in a Recovery Month celebration near you.

Posted by Arnie on 30 Jul 09 06:46 PM EDT
Bring the money home!!!

Posted by maxwood on 31 Jul 09 05:24 PM EDT
Another suggestion would be to reverse the policy of the last thirty years, legalize relatively safe rational methods of cannabis use in western countries, and send advisors to Afghanistan to help farmers convert from poppy to cannabis crops, including refining THC and loading it into e-cigarette cartridges for safe measurable medical use worldwide.

Posted by Julian on 31 Jul 09 05:47 PM EDT
Rob has the right idea. Imagine taking that money, or better yet the money we spend fighting the Taliban in Afganistan and Pakistan and put it into prevention,treatment,and recovery. In a very short time the Taliban would run low on money and... peoples lives would be saved here and there. Treat addiction, save lives.

SUBMIT A COMMENT:

Note: Comments are now held for moderator approval. More info

Name:

Comment:
(limit 250
words)

Enter this word
(help):
Change

GUIDELINES: 
Please keep comments on-topic, courteous, clean, non-commercial, and within the word limit.
Read the complete guidelines