Stay Informed

Sign up for news & alerts

Already signed up?
Login here

take action
For every $1 states spend dollar sign on substance misuse and addiction, 94 cents go to shovel up the consequences instead of for treatment and prevention. TELL YOUR LEGISLATORS

What Can I Do?



Continuing Education
Free online courses for addiction counselors LEARN ONLINE

Get Help
Need alcohol or drug help for yourself or someone else? GET HELP

 

Ex-Marine Webb to Tackle Prison Reform in Senate
January 7, 2009

Share Share Email
Email
Print
Print
SubscribeSubscribe
News Summary

Influential U.S. Sen. Jim Webb (D-Va.) plans to make prison reform a top priority in the new Congress, including clearing prison cells of low-level drug offenders so they can be used to house violent criminals, the Washington Post reported Dec. 29.

Observers say that Webb's military background and tough reputation make him an intriguing figure to lead the charge on prison reform, perhaps insulating him from charges of coddling criminals in a law-and-order state.

"It's perceived as a great political sin to represent any position besides 'lock 'em up and throw the key away,'" said state Sen. J. Chapman Petersen (D-Fairfax). "With Jim's personality, he's never going to strike somebody as being soft on crime or any other issue."

Webb said he wants a prison system that's tough but fair. "I think you can be a law-and-order leader and still understand that the criminal-justice system as we understand it today is broken, unfair, locking up the wrong people in many cases and not locking up the right person in many cases," he said.

Webb decried the disproportionate incarceration of African-Americans and criticized enforcement efforts that focus too heavily on low-level drug offenders and parole violators, saying that individuals who perpetrate violence should be the main focus of law enforcement. However, Tom Riley, a spokesperson for the Office of National Drug Control Policy, called the notion that large numbers of nonviolent offenders are in prison an "urban myth."

"It's true, we have way too many people in prison," he said. "But it's not because the laws are unjust, but because there are too many people who are causing havoc and misery in the community."

Webb wants to establish a national panel to review the nation's criminal-justice system and propose changes. He lauded Japan's prison system, which he said had shorter sentences but in more austere conditions, and focused on rehabilitation, not retribution.

COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE:
(Comments now appear first to last)

Posted by Paul H on 08 Jan 09 08:59 AM EST
We have an overcrowding situation in our prison system. My opinion is that we need to go back to the days when we "Hang 'em High" on the courthouse lawns! This will deter crime.

Posted by Golden Bicep on 08 Jan 09 09:41 AM EST
I think the last line of this piece is actually the most important: "focused on rehabilitation, not retribution." Let's help people have better lives once they get out of prison!

Posted by Luis M. Lozano on 08 Jan 09 10:42 AM EST
Finally someone is going against the influential Prison Industrial Complex. I will pay close attention to his efforts to reform our prisons and sentencing of drug offenders to prison. As a treatment provider who deals with many of the men who come to us after they have been in prison I have seen that many of them had no reason to be in prison. Addiction is a disease and if we don't address the root causes of their drug use we run the risk of incarcerating people for long periods of time, costing tax payers millions of dollars and end up with angry, disenfranchised individuals who will end up becoming hard core criminals.

Posted by Jim Dickey on 08 Jan 09 11:45 AM EST
Morality laws are a waste of time and money and their prosecution only damages our society. Most people in our society use one or more drugs but we have chosen to make some legal and therefore inexpensive while we have made others illegal and expensive. This schizophrenic policy results in an increase of property crimes, the wasting of prison dollars, and irreparable damage to individuals who arbitrarily get caught up in the prison system. I applaud Senator Webb for seeking a better way of dealing with the problems surrounding our ancient propensity to alter our consciousness.

Posted by Vickie on 08 Jan 09 12:00 PM EST
What about the drug dealers? Rehabilitation isn't going to help them. They may not be forcably killing people but they are still killing people. They are business people not addicts and need to be treated as violent offenders.

Posted by Jim Dickey on 08 Jan 09 12:34 PM EST
It's true that drug dealers, like people who are involved in the alcohol and tobacco industries or who sell alcohol and tobacco in stores or who advertise either of those drugs, aid and abet drug use and overdoses. Generally, overdoses occur because the purity of drugs in an unregulated market varies greatly. Fighting over drug turf and the deaths it causes also occur in such markets. It shouldn't be too hard to come up with a better solution than what we have now. If you look around the world, many countries are handling the problems much better than we are.

Posted by wanda gilson on 08 Jan 09 02:50 PM EST
My son has been serving a 20 year sentence for dwi 4th. Our attorney told us not to appeal take a guilty plea. His only has 3 dwi's the police officer is alway right. We asked for treatment and was denied. His probation officer was sent to jail for 3 years for malfience in office. My son was in drug court and had a slip. He was a junior in college and working for a builder, not a violent criminal. Cenacoroffered him a rehab for free the jusges laughed and threw the papers in the air. I have been in Alanon for 28 years. My husband is a recovering alcholic. Louisiana spends more money on incarceration than education. It is a money making industry. The attorneys, drug courts, and da's make a lot of money.

Posted by honest girl on 08 Jan 09 03:26 PM EST
Louisiana incarcerates all alcholics. They spent more money on incarceration than education. I have been in alanon for 32 years. My son was sentenced to 20 years for dwi 4. no accidents neverdriving the car, was in drug court and slipped. He never got treatment. He was a junior in college and working his way through school. He has no other charges. One of the dwi's was not his, but attorney said not to appeal they are always right. His probation officer was sent to jail for 3 years, malfeance in office. Centacor offered my son treatment and the judges threw the papers nin the air and laughed. He has never had treatment.

Posted by John from Oceanside on 08 Jan 09 04:04 PM EST
I think this is great because he will find out the lies that drug legalizers have be saying. Legalizers claim people are in prison for smoking weed, when in reality they are in for more serious crimes and have have a weed charge also.

Posted by Jim Dickey on 08 Jan 09 05:04 PM EST
In reality, nearly 1 out of 8 U.S. drug prisoners are locked up for pot ( http://www.lewrockwell.com/armentano-p/armentano-p12.htm). I realize some of these convictions were plea bargains but that's like saying if there were a law on the books making it illegal to posses paper it would be a good law because it would allow us to convict people who committed more serious crimes of possession of paper through the plea bargain process. I do not think incarceration for the mere possession of marijuana is a good idea and I don't think sending Wanda's son to prison for 20 years is a particularly bright thing to do or advocate. I would think sentencing him to house arrest with an ankle bracelet and taking away his car and drivers license would have sufficed. An ankle bracelet with wireless capabilities and connected to a GPS system which would send an alarm notification if he traveled at auto speeds would be just as effective and way cheaper than the $1,000,000 price tag of 20 years in prison.

Posted by Brinna Nanda on 08 Jan 09 10:00 PM EST
Prison stocks trade on Wall Street and profits are based on how many people are in jail. That is a horrible conflict of interest. Prisons should absolutely not be businesses, otherwise love of money will always trump public welfare.

Posted by Shelley on 08 Jan 09 10:13 PM EST
Vickie you don't know what you're talking about. I used to deal to support my habit. I've been in recovery for 5 years, and the business I'm in now is to show people that getting clean and sober is definitely worth it and can be done. I have a lot to give back.

Posted by Donald B Parsons on 09 Jan 09 09:55 AM EST
Vickie, to use the word violent to cover drug dealers is wrong as ALL dealers are NOT violent. I do not know ALL drug dealers but the ones I have encountered through the years are only prone to violence when drinking and the violence usually had nothing to do with the drug trade. Selling drugs is NOT violent, using drugs is NOT violent, albeit are illegal but NOT to the tune of the DISPROPORTIONATE PUNISHMENT dished out for MINOR drug offenses.

Posted by Donald B Parsons on 09 Jan 09 10:22 AM EST
I APPLAUD Sen. Webb as this is an overdue mission. I was APPAULED last year when I first heard of TRADING on WALL ST. according to the prison population numbers(HOW SICKENING). John from Oceanside, You may be technically correct in saying that people are not incarcerated for "smoking" cannabis, but are put behind bars for NON-VIOLENT drug related offenses. I have a friend that was incarcerated shortly after a minor traffic offense (tail light out). I do not know why the officer asked to search the vehicle but my friend allowed the search fearing worse punishment down the road if he refused. The officer found 32 grams of cannabis which my friend did 2 years for on top of having to pay all court costs and counseling after serving his time (for mere possesion).

Posted by Kris Reinertson on 10 Jan 09 09:18 PM EST
I applaud Sen. Webb as well for his courage to tackle this issue that is the 2 ton gorilla in the room that politicians fear most. "Soft on drugs" is rhetoric used monotonously. It takes a strong, brave politician to overcome the tough/soft dichotomy and deliver pragmatic solutions to this complex problem. However, clearing prison cells is a half-step. We need a sustainable solution. Decriminalize adult marijuana consumption first, along with eliminating the crack/cocaine disparity, and then move to a regulated and controlled system while confronting adult drug use through public health campaigns and strategies.

Posted by Lindy B on 12 Jan 09 12:44 PM EST
I agree with Jim and Luis. I am a CDPT and am convinced that mental health issues, and chemical dependency are intractably linked. If we don't stop locking up our mentally ill, and addicted we will continue to burden our society with over crowed prisons and unsustainable costs. Besides, it's cheaper to treat than to lock up, not to mention incarceration of mentally ill and sick is very barbaric doesn't solve the problem. Out of site, and out of mind is not working anymore. Perhaps if treatment were more accessable and affordable, we would find our prisons not so crowded. If we don't get a handle on this, however, we are going to have a huge problem when our baby boomers hit old age. The elderly are the fastest growing population in this country and have addiction issues with prescription and illicit drugs as well as alcohol. We could find our children visiting us old boomers in prison!

Posted by Lisa Leon on 12 Jan 09 02:08 PM EST
Recover, Restoration, and human dignity is worth it. We are in a crisis on so many levels and it is a shame when we don't have the human compassion to encourage people who are lost and are struggling with the fight of their lives. I am in recovery too and without the opportunities afforded me I would still be out on the streets doing everything I said I would never do to support a habit. I know there are people in there who deserve a second chance because I was one of them. But no more and now I have dedicated my life to help people who are open to receive it.

Posted by Lisa Leon on 12 Jan 09 02:15 PM EST
Lives are worth being saved and anyone in objection to that must reevaluate their thinking patterns. People are dying on drug and alcohol and some of them want to get it together. With no opportunities to do so we would actually kill humanity. The easiest thing to do is lock people up when we don't understand their struggles especially when we are victims but there is not one family that I know of who has not been affected by this in some way. People are healing and getting better and it is because there are people who care and are creating opportunities and joining programs that support their efforts. I can clearly see that Webb is a prime example of Prayer changes things, but that is just my opinion.

Posted by John on 12 Jan 09 06:43 PM EST
Wanda,I'm sorry about your son, but something is not being told here. As a drug court couselor I have never seen anyone get twenty years and never sentenced out period, for being dirty. And "drug courts make a lot of money" what a joke. My drug court is one of the oldest in the country(1992) and fees etc only pay for 40% of the cost, the other alternative sentencing programs in Community Corrections make up the difference.

Your Turn! Post a public comment (guidelines):

Name:

Comment:
(limit 250
words)

Enter this word
(help):
Change

GUIDELINES: 
To keep this feature useful for everyone, please:

  1. Keep it clean, courteous, brief, and on-topic. Comments are for discussion of the above article, not general rants or manifestos. Serial comments intended to circumvent the 250-word limit may be deleted.

  2. Do not post promotional web links, personal information or requests for assistance (get help).

  3. Proof your comments carefully, use good spelling and punctuation, and don't use ALL CAPS. Comments are published immediately and cannot be edited.

Deceptive, slanderous and commercial posts are prohibited. We reserve the right to remove comments. (Report a comment).

Have questions or feedback? Contact us.