Jury Rules Against Medical Monitoring for Smokers November 16, 2001
News Summary
An Ohio County, W.Va., jury gave a major victory to the tobacco industry when it ruled against medical screening for healthy West Virginia smokers, MSNBC reported Nov. 14.The jury heard arguments in a class-action lawsuit brought by 250,000 West Virginia smokers. The lawsuit called for tobacco companies to subsidize medical monitoring for the early detection of lung cancer, emphysema, and other smoking-related illnesses.
After two days of deliberations, the jury ruled that cigarettes are not a defective product, and that cigarette makers were not negligent in designing, making, or selling them.
While jurors said they recognized that those who have been smoking a pack-a-day for five or more years have an increased risk of contracting a smoking-related disease, they ruled against the need for medical monitoring.
COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE: